Amish Community Cookbook

I am just like my grandmother, I love cookbooks.  Granny used to sit in the evening and read cookbooks just like she was reading a novel.  I do the same thing and love marking recipes that I’d like to try.

I recently had the opportunity to review a newly released cookbook, Amish Community Cookbook:  simply Delicious Recipes from Amish and Mennonite Homes.

Amish Community Cookbook - This cookbook is full of recipes your family will love.

Affiliate links are included in this post.

I grew up just east of the Shenandoah Valley where there are quite a few Mennonite farms.

Both my mom and my grandmother had copies of the Mennonite Community Cookbook and I can remember my mom in particular using this cookbook quite often.

Since I knew for a fact that my mom and grandmother both enjoyed recipes from their Mennonite cookbooks, I was pretty sure that I would really enjoy the Amish Community Cookbook and I was correct.

I inherited Granny’s copy of the Mennonite Community Cookbook.  Granny’s marked pages to identify recipes she wanted to try or ones that she wanted to remember

Mennonite Community Cookbook


Peach Marlow was either a recipe she tried or wanted to try.  I love seeing her handwriting.

Peach Marlow from the Mennonite Community Cookbook


Let’s talk about the Amish Community Cookbook.

Amish Community Cookbook includes these sections:

  • Drinks and Appetizers
  • Soups, Salads, and Dressings
  • Casseroles and Main Dishes
  • Side Dishes and Vegetables
  • Breads and Breakfast Foods
  • Canning Recipes
  • Jams and Jellies
  • Desserts and Sweets


The cookbook is full of pictures like this one, that remind me so much of the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia.

Amish Community Cookbook


Back when Mr. SP and I did a lot of bicycle riding, we spent a lot of time cycling roads in Rockingham and Augusta Counties where we saw farm scenes much like this one.

Amish Community Cookbook


I have enjoyed the pretty pictures in this book as much as I’ve enjoyed looking through the recipes.

Amish Community CookbookAmish Community Cookbook


Not only are recipes included in this book, there are helpful hints as well.

Amish Community CookbookAmish Community Cookbook


Recipes I’ve Tried from the Book

I have tried three recipes from this book:  Poor Man’s Steak, Ham and Noodle Bake, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies.

Poor Man’s Steak

I first tried Poor Man’s Steak, a combination of ground beef and cracker crumbs topped with a can of cream of mushroom soup.

The quote beside this recipe in the book says this:

This recipe is always a surprise for guests.   It tastes like a delicious cut of beef rather than just ground beef.

I didn’t find the quote to be true but we enjoyed the meal.


Ham and Noodle Bake

I used some leftover ham from Easter to make Ham Noodle Bake.  I’m sure to make this recipe time and again.  We really enjoyed it.

This picture was sent to me by the publisher of the book but it doesn’t perfectly match the recipe as this picture shows peas in the Ham Noodle Bake and the recipe doesn’t call for them.

Ham Noodle Bake


Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

I made these cookies last Friday to take to the lake for Mother’s Day.

These are the last three cookies leftover from the weekend.  Mr. SP and his dad made short work of this large batch of cookies.  I’d say that’s a good recommendation for this recipe!

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies - From the Amish Community Cookbook  -


This cookie was easy to make and definitely was enjoyed.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

If you are in the market for a new cookbook, you will enjoy the Amish Community Cookbook.  I like that it’s filled with recipes that not only are easy to make, but also don’t take a lot of ingredients or a long time to make.

I’m sure to make many more recipes from this cookbook.


    1. I am really enjoying this cookbook! The pictures and tips in it are just as much enjoyment as reading the recipes.

    1. I am really enjoying this book. I just looked up More with Less, it also looks like one I would enjoy.

    1. I have tried three recipes from it and have more marked to try. I like that the recipes are all easy and don’t require a long list of ingredients.

  1. Hello Paula! I’m from amish country (PA) and my mother was also an ‘amish cookbook collector’ and would sit and read them just as I would read a great novel! (funny). I have quite a few amish/menonnite cookbooks and I’m sure I even have the very same one as yours above! I haven’t looked at them for quite some time but your post has me wanting to read them again!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.