Turkey Reuben

In our town, a local favorite bar and grill is The Cavalier Store, known by locals simply as “The Cav.”  Mr. SP ate many evening meals at the bar shown below before he met me.  The Cav has the best seasoned thick-cut fries that you’ll ever taste and for bar food, it is pretty tasty.
untitled

Source

The interior is decorated with local pennants and donated license plates.  The tables and booths are carved with initials and unfortunately in recent years, scribbled over in Sharpie graffiti.  There’s a lot to look at while you wait for your food.
untitled3

I couldn’t count how many meals we’ve eaten here.  One of our favorite sandwiches at The Cav is a grilled turkey reuben.  After eating my first one at The Cav back in 1993, I created my own version that we enjoy at home that makes a quick and easy dinner and is certainly a bit more healthy than the usual reuben made with corned beef.
Grilled Turkey Reuben - Turkey and swiss grilled on rye bread with 1,000 Island dressing and sauerkraut makes a tasty sandwich.  virginiasweetpea.com
 Scroll down for a printable recipe.
Turkey Rueben
Ingredients:
Rye bread
Deli turkey slices
Swiss cheese
Sauerkraut
Thousand Island salad dressing

Spray butter or regular butter

Grilled Turkey Reuben - Turkey and swiss grilled on rye bread with 1,000 Island dressing and sauerkraut makes a tasty sandwich.  virginiasweetpea.com

A nonstick skillet or regular skillet will work just fine for making these sandwiches but I typically use my grill and waffle maker.  (affiliate link)
Black and Decker Grill and Wafflemaker
Directions:
1.  Butter one side of each bread slice.  Turn one slice butter side down.
2.  On the butter side down slice, layer turkey, cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing.
3.  Put the other slice of bread on top, butter side up.
Grilled Turkey Reuben - Turkey and swiss grilled on rye bread with 1,000 Island dressing and sauerkraut makes a tasty sandwich.  virginiasweetpea.com
4. Grill and enjoy!
Grilled Turkey Reuben - Turkey and swiss grilled on rye bread with 1,000 Island dressing and sauerkraut makes a tasty sandwich.  virginiasweetpea.com

A little mustard might be a good addition to this sandwich. Next time I’ll add that.

What do you think?  Is this something that you might enjoy?

Turkey Reuben
 
Author:
Ingredients
  • Rye bread
  • Deli turkey slices
  • Swiss cheese
  • Sauerkraut
  • Thousand Island salad dressing
  • Spray butter or regular butter
Instructions
  1. Butter one side of each bread slice. Turn one slice butter side down.
  2. On the butter side down slice, layer turkey, cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing.
  3. Put the other slice of bread on top, butter side up.
  4. Grill and enjoy!

Grilled Turkey Reuben - Turkey and swiss grilled on rye bread with 1,000 Island dressing and sauerkraut makes a tasty sandwich. virginiasweetpea.com

Comments

  1. Kelly J/Hunters Hill says:

    Paula – I also have a B&D waffle iron that I use to make paninis…. it’s almost exactly like yours, it was a wedding present in 1990!

  2. Anonymous says:

    Well, that’s just the craziest thing! I looked at your waffle maker and thought to myself, “That looks just like mine!” But I never realized it was also a grill! Sure enough I just checked and the plates reverse to a grill! I can’t believe I never noticed it! Mine was also a wedding present back in the 90’s. Looks like we’ll be having grilled sandwiches today! 🙂

  3. Paula, that looks yummy! A reuben is one of the hubbies favorite sandwiches.

  4. jennifer says:

    I am going to have to make this!!!

  5. Amanda @ Serenity Now says:

    Droooooling!! That looks so, so good, Paula!

  6. Honey at 2805 says:

    My ancient Sears waffle iron (which weights a ton) is also a griddle. This sandwich is making me hungry.

    The age of the waffle iron makes me digress a bit. We recently cleaned out my Mom’s home and when I saw her iron no lightweight itself), I thought about the 3 I have at home which do not get hot enough. There must be some kind of government control on that. Anyway I brought hers home and it’s amazing the difference it makes. Now, I rarely iron anthing, but when I do I want it flat with no wrinkles. Maybe I’ll post about this.

  7. FrouFrouBritches says:

    That place looks like my kind of place!

    I’m not a fan of sauerkraut, but I think my Hubby would love this! He likes everything in it.

    I gotta find my sandwich press thing. Thanks for the reminder.

  8. Miss Char says:

    I’ll be right over Paula, Rubens of any sort are one of my favorite sandwiches.

  9. Katie @ On the Banks of Squaw Creek says:

    Nat’l Turkey Fed is having a contest for recipes just like this – where you make the meal healthier by substituting turkey! You should enter this – it looks delicious! The details are at mealupgrade.com

  10. Amanda @ Serenity Now says:

    Now I’m hungry again!! 😉 Ha…at least I’m getting ready to go out to eat for girls’ night. 😉 Thanks for linking up, Paula!

Speak Your Mind

*

Rate this recipe:  

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.